23 Oct 2010

Ill mannered commenter gets it wrong

The facility for visitors to comment anonymously is intended for employees in the benefits system, who for obvious reasons can't leave their names (though this does sometimes stop me following up interesting points). It's also used by the occasional claimant. That's fine too.

However, an anonymous commenter here uses the facility to say
Please at least read the government's documents properly and not just the headlines. There's been no jump in the figures, just inaccurate reporting.
I had reported that "the coalition government says welfare fraud costs £5.2 billion pounds a year".

Well I am pretty sure I heard George Osborne say that in his Commons speech. Now, where might he have got that from?

In the DWP document which I referenced in the post, the Ministerial Foreword states that
This document sets out a radical new approach for addressing welfare fraud, which now costs the taxpayer £5.2 billion pounds every year, or £165 every second.
Take your indignation to Lord Freud and David Gauke, then.

3 comments:

Mark Wadsworth said...

£5.2 billion is at the lower end of the range. Have you added in the £2 billion or £3 billion overpaid Tax Credits every year?

Anonymous said...

There are 2 types of overpayment, those that are to be paid back and those who are prosecuted so the "error" isn't an error by the staff dealing with it but an error by the claimant. Usually failure to notify a change in circustances. The case your blog highlights are the more blantant claims which result in prosecution.

Errors made by staff are official errors and are non-recoverable.

Deaf Tim said...

Shame on you, John; you know that they conflate fraud and error. I take my indignation to both you and this vile government.